5 replies to this topic

[kirkifer]

I am not sure what is going on here...

Roxio Media Import finally seems to work well with analog video capture when I use an approved card.   I am using a brand new Hauppauge PVR 150 MCE (32 bit drivers installed) capture card.

I have one big problem...  I can only capture in the three MPEG-2 levels.  According to the help menu, I should also be able to capture in VCD and DV.  I believe both 1of these files are less compressed formats.  I prefer the bigger, less compressed, files for editing.

Does anyone know why I do not have the DV or VCD option available to me?  I am using a supported capture card.

Edited by kirkifer, 13 December 2006 - 02:26 PM.

[ggrussell]

But does the CARD support those formats? Probably not.  VCD is MPEG 1 and is not as high quality as MPEG 2.

[Beerman]

ggrussell, on Dec 14 2006, 07:47 AM, said:

But does the CARD support those formats? Probably not.  VCD is MPEG 1 and is not as high quality as MPEG 2.

No, this card is a hardware MPEG2 encoder.  MPEG1 is not supported.

[kirkifer]

Man, that is funny....  This is more rocket science to this than folks realize...

I have heard of people building super computers that do nothing but video editing (i.e. no virus protection, e-mail, etc...)

So, what is the best consumer/prosumer grade capture card that Roxio supports?

[ggrussell]

I went through about 10 analog cards and ended up just buying a digital camcorder that has pass-through feature.  Better supported and have a new digital camcorder to record future family events, too. <G>  With the prices dropping, that may be a better choice.

Prices are also dropping on set top recorders which could be another choice, but some users still have trouble getting those recorded videos into Videowave/MyDVD.

A TV card is good for watching and recording TV.

[kirkifer]

Yes, here is the rub....

I only have a limited need for AVI capture since I now use mini-DV as my recording medium...  IMHO, mini-DV will be the medium that stays around in the better consumer/prosumer video cameras.

The biggest crisis I have with any MPEG encoder (Hauppauge card or desktop recorder) is that highly compressed formats are not ideal for editing and re-compression.  I am sure that is why camcorders that write MPEG to a HDD or a DVD are not prefered by people wanting super crisp image files....  

Edited by kirkifer, 14 December 2006 - 07:49 AM.