Jump to content
  • 0
pmoore603

Incorrect Aspect Ratio

Question

I created 6 shorts using videowave, a separate production for each. The productions each consist of a couple dozen video clips, some overlaid audio and text as well. I output the projects as 6 mpg files. The productions all format properly for 16:9 when viewed on the computer. Then, I created a mydvd project, also 16:9, and dragged in each mpg. The preview project works at 16:9.

 

I get different results with the burned dvd however:

 

- Played from my computer, aspect ratio is correct at 16:9 for everything.

- played from my dvd player on a widescreen tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

- played from a PS3 on a 4:3 tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

 

I would have expected the production to have black bars on the top and bottom for a 4:3 destination. Any thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

9 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

I created 6 shorts using videowave, a separate production for each. The productions each consist of a couple dozen video clips, some overlaid audio and text as well. I output the projects as 6 mpg files. The productions all format properly for 16:9 when viewed on the computer. Then, I created a mydvd project, also 16:9, and dragged in each mpg. The preview project works at 16:9.

 

I get different results with the burned dvd however:

 

- Played from my computer, aspect ratio is correct at 16:9 for everything.

- played from my dvd player on a widescreen tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

- played from a PS3 on a 4:3 tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

 

I would have expected the production to have black bars on the top and bottom for a 4:3 destination. Any thoughts?

 

 

How have you got the DVD player hooked up your TV?. You may have to change the settings on your TV input (HDMI/Component/Composite).

Edited by ogdens

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I created 6 shorts using videowave, a separate production for each. The productions each consist of a couple dozen video clips, some overlaid audio and text as well. I output the projects as 6 mpg files. The productions all format properly for 16:9 when viewed on the computer. Then, I created a mydvd project, also 16:9, and dragged in each mpg. The preview project works at 16:9.

 

I get different results with the burned dvd however:

 

- Played from my computer, aspect ratio is correct at 16:9 for everything.

- played from my dvd player on a widescreen tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

- played from a PS3 on a 4:3 tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

 

I would have expected the production to have black bars on the top and bottom for a 4:3 destination. Any thoughts?

 

If the DVD plays correctly on your computer then the software worked correctly. The problem may well be in your DVD player and/or TV setup.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

How have you got the DVD player hooked up your TV?. You may have to change the settings on your TV input (HDMI/Component/Composite).

It's component. I also tried HDMI (only just noticed today that it has an HDMI output, LOL). Same behavior either way.

 

If the DVD plays correctly on your computer then the software worked correctly. The problem may well be in your DVD player and/or TV setup.

That's what I was wondering. Could it be a lousy DVD player? I'm pretty sure I have viewed widescreen movie DVD's on it before though...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

It's component. I also tried HDMI (only just noticed today that it has an HDMI output, LOL). Same behavior either way.

 

 

That's what I was wondering. Could it be a lousy DVD player? I'm pretty sure I have viewed widescreen movie DVD's on it before though...

 

It is most likely in the setup of your TV and/or DVD player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Most likely your Player settings, you will have to look deep into its' menu to find them ;)

 

In VideoWave (your editor) you must set what the Project will be BEFORE you start!

 

You can select 1 of 2 way for how it will handle non-widescreen clips when added. This is both a global setting (File Preferences) as well as an individual clip (right click) adjustment you can make on the fly.

 

In MyDVD it simple does whatever the source is and the only choice is in a DVD Project concerning How The MENU will be (4:3 or 16:9)...

 

If your VideoWave Project was Widescreen, MyDVD will consider it a widescreen source.

 

Of course ALL HD Project are automatically widescreen but the Source files must be widescreen as well as there is no Global setting in MyDVD.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I created 6 shorts using videowave, a separate production for each. The productions each consist of a couple dozen video clips, some overlaid audio and text as well. I output the projects as 6 mpg files. The productions all format properly for 16:9 when viewed on the computer. Then, I created a mydvd project, also 16:9, and dragged in each mpg. The preview project works at 16:9.

 

I get different results with the burned dvd however:

 

- Played from my computer, aspect ratio is correct at 16:9 for everything.

- played from my dvd player on a widescreen tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

- played from a PS3 on a 4:3 tv, aspect ratio is 4:3.

 

I would have expected the production to have black bars on the top and bottom for a 4:3 destination. Any thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I get the same problems with my older Roxio Easy CD and DVD Burning program. It shows it's set to record as 16:9 but when I play it back on a DVD player its 4:3. At other times it actually does record as 16:9, but you never know when that will be. I can't tell you how many DVDs I've wasted trying to get a proper format recording. Roxio is junk. I'm going to look on the net for something else.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I get the same problems with my older Roxio Easy CD and DVD Burning program. It shows it's set to record as 16:9 but when I play it back on a DVD player its 4:3. At other times it actually does record as 16:9, but you never know when that will be. I can't tell you how many DVDs I've wasted trying to get a proper format recording. Roxio is junk. I'm going to look on the net for something else.

 

Did you actually read the posts in this thread before starting your silly rant. You can search the net all you want you want get any different results.

If your use the correct source, have the correct settings the program works correctly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I get the same problems with my older Roxio Easy CD and DVD Burning program. It shows it's set to record as 16:9 but when I play it back on a DVD player its 4:3. At other times it actually does record as 16:9, but you never know when that will be. I can't tell you how many DVDs I've wasted trying to get a proper format recording. Roxio is junk. I'm going to look on the net for something else.

Apples to Oranges! That is a completely different program and very limited by its' design!

 

You can only set the ratio of the MENU...

 

post-39730-086970400 1333097321.jpg

The 'Content' of the project will remain in the aspect ration that it was created in :huh:

 

There is NO provision to change the aspect ration of the pictures or video you add as there is in the full version.

 

It is little things like this that make up the difference between a $30 program and a $100 full Suite! ;)

 

You did mention Capture??? :glare: If you are using the Roxio Video Capture Device USB, it can only capture as 4:3... To "Capture" in 16:9, you can only do that with a Firewire connection.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×