Sorry for the late response, I was waiting for my new HDMI Splitter to come in. Thankfully, after figuring everything out I was able to record gameplay with no problems whatsoever! I actually had to go back to Best Buy to purchase an HDMI cable to match the odd one I have, as the Pearlstone HDMI cables didn't seem to work. Thank you so much, Jim & Dewey! I'm usually weary to go to support forums as i've never seen much good help come from them, but this was quite the opposite case!